Ah yes, the classic early 90's R.E.M. trilogy. Whether or not you personally believe all three albums work well together as a set of emotions (happiness, sadness, and anger respectively), these albums were incredibly popular at the time, and possibly still are. "Automatic for the People" would most likely go on my list of top ten albums of all time; it's an album I still listen to with some frequency, and one that never, ever gets old. "Sweetness Follows" is perhaps also in my top 10 or 20 songs, and I feel emotionally attached to it.
Chronologically, I'm quite certain that "Out of Time" was in our house soon after its release, whether on the strength of the singles ("Losing My Religion" is also still an incredible, wonderful song.) or not, I couldn't say. I also don't remember having any other R.E.M. albums around, so again, I can't say why my dad brought "Out of Time" home. I do remember quite clearly listening to "Shiny Happy People" before we moved out of the first house, which happened late in seventh grade. The other albums must've also come home right around the times of their release, and I'm fairly certain "Monster" was the kind of album I prioritized so much that I got it either on the day of release, or the week of.
R.E.M. was my first concert, and it was the "Monster" tour that I saw. I remember very clearly every bit of that show--from Michael Stipe's lyric sheets to the wonderment of R.E.M. songs like "Fall on Me" that I didn't know. After the concert, I believe that I systematically acquired every single R.E.M. album, starting at Murmur and moving forward. And I really still think that but for a few clunkers (I don't love "Reckoning", their sophomore effort), the band has put out a remarkable number of insanely good albums. And while I put "Automatic for the People" in my top 10, I don't necessarily always say that it's my favorite R.E.M. album. Strange, eh? But the emotional attachment to AftP is too great to chuck it in favor of "Life's Rich Pageant" or "Green" or "Document". But those R.E.M. albums only entered my collection due to the other three, and the love of the other three that led me to see R.E.M. in concert.
And I don't think it's only the music that's important to me. I can't remember a time when I wasn't fascinated by Michael Stipe, and the things he represented. I loved (and still love) his propensity for gender fuck. I probably love eyeliner on men so much because Michael Stipe used to wear it and oh man, used to look beautiful in it. Also, my Michael Stipe never had hair. He just had the beautiful shaved head, and his androgyny (which includes the eyeliner) always appealed to me. I've always thought Michael Stipe was sexy, both for his looks and his attitude. And his lyrics. They can be nonsensical, but I've found things in them. He isn't conventional, that's for sure, and I think I'm drawn to that in both men and women. I'm not sure if that's how I felt as a sophomore in high school (when I saw that first R.E.M. show), because I'm not sure I was that conscious of such things, but I do know that I did always find him devilishly attractive. It's very hard to say where one part of his appeal ends and another begins, at least time-wise.
Also, I'm almost 100% positive that my copy of "Out of Time" is in fact that first one that my dad brought home all those years ago. So....yeah, sorry, dad. I stole your copy of the album and now it lives with me. It's probably time for me to buy a new one, though, because it's scratched to shit, and I can say without hesitation that at least two or three of the tracks are unplayable. And I am definitely on my 2nd copy of AftP. "Monster", though, didn't hold up so well. I rarely listen to it, and it wouldn't be at all close to my top R.E.M. albums. And I haven't bought a new R.E.M. album in ages, though I did like "Reveal" quite a bit. There is an R.E.M. album dropping in 2008, and maybe I'll check it out. Or maybe tomorrow I'll just listen to copious amounts of the R.E.M. I already have, since typing this has made me want to.