I read Dooce mostly to laugh. Doesn't everyone? Heather's posts about life with Jon and Leta are brilliantly funny. But sometimes, when Dooce gets serious, I remember why the internets really loves her. There is an honesty about Heather that hits you right between the eyes, in a good way. And I don't know about other women, but sometimes, I feel like she is speaking for me. Today's post is one of those.
I obviously don't have kids, and I've also been pretty clear on the fact that I don't want them. But actually, I waver. Every great once in a while, I imagine what it might be like to have a child. And the truth is, I can't see myself doing mommy things. I can't see being anything but impatient with a baby, even in my imaginings. I won't apologize for it, because at least I'm not intending to go into motherhood thinking this. The only way I could consent to having a child is if I could somehow get past this sense of things. I can't see getting there, though. I don't remember if Heather ever talked about wanting a baby, or the lead-up to the pregnancy. So I don't know if she felt like this, or if Leta was highly anticipated, and the schism in Heather's head about being a mommy was a shock at birth. But I imagine it's the second, and that's different from how I feel, and I know it. I don't think my situation is anything like Heather's, honestly. I already know that I could never stay home with a kid. I already know that I wouldn't be the kind of mommy that wanted only to be with her child. I don't think I'd have to spend time accepting that my motherhood would be different from the traditional view of it. I already know it would. I accept that.
The thing I don't know, and the thing that will absolutely prevent me from having a child until I figure it out, is if I could be anything but indifferent towards the idea. I certainly feel no great passion for it. Sometimes I find reasons that I think are good--my mom would be the cutest grandma ever, the world needs more children of intelligent liberal parents--and I realize that these reasons aren't good at all. The most important reason, feeling a desire to parent, is utterly lacking within me. I joke with Sam about it, how he can stay home with the kid and do all the (traditionally) mommy stuff and I'll come in at the end of the day and kiss the kid before it goes to bed. It's a horrific thing to condemn a kid to, a parent so uninvolved with their life, and I can't help feeling that that's where we'll eventually end up if we have a child, because I simply have no interest in that stuff.
Before you all yell at me that it changes when it's your own kids and blah blah blah, you'll love your kid so much all that stuff will go away and you'll love holding your screaming baby and it all makes it worth it, and you know, all that shit, stop and think for a minute if you think every woman who has children is happy that she did. We are not all the same, just because we're women and possess uteri, and so can you not admit that there might be women who in fact do not organically want children? And that it might be a mistake for women who are lukewarm about the prospect to go through with it because they are women, and that is what they are supposed to do? I'm not going to give you a name, but a woman I know recently told me that if she had to do it over, no matter that she loves her children more than herself and that she would give her life for them (they're grown now), she wouldn't have had children. She did it because it was the 70's and women were wives and mothers in the 70's, and there was no space in her head that allowed her to be childless. She said she never did enjoy being a mother, never enjoyed the playgroups and the relentless drive to care for the children. And she stressed that she did love her kids, and felt like they enriched her life, but still. She wasn't meant for it, and she said she knew that now.
I think I'm that woman. I think that for the first time, ever, women are allowing themselves the space to live without giving birth, without being mommies, and I think it's okay. I think I'm one of those women who would never truly enjoy her children, never enjoy the mommying. I feel so right about this most of the time. I'm not saying I couldn't do it, I guess, but I am saying that I'm almost 100% certain that I shouldn't. It's different, and when all those people in my life tell me, "Oh, someday, you will want children, you'll see" I think they simply just do not get it. Just because I have one doesn't mean I should use it. It doesn't make me sad, the prospect of never parenting. It exhilarates me, it makes me feel free, it gives me relief. I feel more grief about the fact that I might feel pressured to have a child, because I worry Sam will ultimately leave me over the issue. Again, not a real reason to have a child.
I know I'm not alone in this, and I know there are other women like that one in the paragraphs above, the one who admitted regretting having children. (Because lest you want to put a name on it, that's exactly what it was. I have to make it clear; I admire this woman very much for being honest about it, and in fact respect her greatly anyway.) It's such a no-no, now, to say that you wish you'd done it differently, and not had children, as if that somehow disrespected the children you had. I don't see it that way, of course. But I understand that some people always will, and those are probably the same people who will continue to tell me that I'll come around and my biological clock will tick and I'll end up with a fat drooly baby on my knee, adoration pouring out of me with every diaper change and 2 am wake-up. There's always going to be those people, both in the wider world and in my life.
I guess, like Heather Armstrong coming to terms with motherhood her way, I am in my way trying to come to terms with motherhood my way. Which may in fact be no motherhood at all. I say it all the time, but I am still trying to grasp the complexities that fuel my feelings on the issue. And I imagine I will be forever, as long as I'm still able to physically bear children (shit, if indeed I am. Because seriously? Who knows.). Anyway, Heather's post made me think about this stuff, and now you're reading it.