« An ode to Paul Anka's new album (stay with me, people) | Main | The free time, oh the free time »

June 18, 2005

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I just started my first Nick Hornby, "How to Be Good," and I'm really having trouble getting into it, because I really don't like the main character so far. However, I will stick with it, because it's for the summer meeting of my book group. These days, the only reason I will persevere with a book I'm not enjoying is if it's "required" reading. Was the movie "High Fidelity" based on Hornby's book? I did like that, although I was lukewarm about Hugh Grant and "About a Boy." S.N.

Manogirl

Yes, High Fidelity (the movie) was loosely based on the book. But so completely loosely that it's really easy to like both without the book getting in the way. In fact, I guess I felt the same way about About a Boy.

I've always thought that Hornby did a great job of making sure his books didn't end up as crappy movies--by sanctioning completely different films. If that makes sense.

I suppose all I can say, really, is that High Fidelity is one of the truest pictures of working in a music store that I've ever seen. From someone who worked in one. Remember when they laughed at the guy who came in for the Stevie Wonder song? Yeah, I'm not saying we laughed at Stevie Wonder fans, but oh, we laughed. And made lists, and argued about what was better. Maybe I like it so much (the book and the movie) because of how true I think it is.

And anyway, I'm a sucker for John Cusack. (And Hugh Grant, btw, which might explain my adoration of About a Boy (the movie).

jwer

High Fidelity is two of my all-time faves; both book and movie. I liked About a Boy marginally better as a book, and I've only seen the Colin Firth Fever Pitch. Which was good if obscure-ish.

Meanwhile, I don't get Eggers either. I really didn't like Might magazine at all, and while I was frequently happy with McSweeney's, it was almost never because of him. I read AHWOSG, and laughed plenty of times, but mostly just wanted to strangle him for being such a smug dick. Ah well.

Just for the record: I finished How to be Good this morning, and now have to say it's one of the best books I've read in a long time! It was true to relationships and life in general the way you thought High Fidelity was true to what it's like to work in a music store. It was depressing and hilarious at the same time. Hornby's now on my list! S.N.

The comments to this entry are closed.